top of page

We Tried the Stranger Things Pizza

  • Writer: Eric
    Eric
  • Jul 8, 2022
  • 1 min read

Updated: Jul 14, 2024

I'm a sucker for marketing gimmicks and this Walmart pickup was definitely an impulse buy. With Stranger Things Season 4 topping the streaming charts, it's nice to know somebody is capitalizing on the hype by actually releasing Surfer Boy Pizza in the frozen food section.



The logo and the box itself looks identical to the ones on Netflix - I guess that's the point right? I love how at first glance you wouldn't think anything of it, and if not for the small Stranger Things logo at the top (or knowing about it from watching the show) you could think this is any other generic frozen pizza with a California vibe.



If you look closely, on the side of the box it says Palermo's, so this is the actual Milwaukee-based manufacturer of the frozen pizza and they are just licensing the Surfer Boy Pizza trademark and design.



So how does it taste? We got the Multi-Meat Pizza with sausage, ham and pepperoni. The ingredients themselves looked fresh and the diced ham was in pretty good sized chunks.



The crust was somewhat yeasty and what I would call sturdy not really hard but definitely not fluffy. It's average to above average, very similar to DiGiorno if you've had that before.


A+ for marketing boys, you got me! Be sure to check out the rest of our Indy Pizza Blog content and the Indy Pizza Map on Google.

5 Comments


greggs menu
greggs menu
a day ago

Greggs breakfast time usually starts early in the morning, around 6:30 am to 7 am depending on the branch. The breakfast menu stays available until 11 am, so it’s best to arrive before then. Many people prefer grabbing a hot coffee and a fresh bacon roll during Greggs breakfast time because it’s quick, tasty, and affordable. https://greggspricemenus.co.uk/greggs-breakfast-times/

Like

menugreggs
Oct 14

We tried the Stranger Things Pizza and it was a total throwback to the '80s! The packaging was super cool with the show's theme, and the Greggs pizza itself was surprisingly tasty—crispy crust, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of spice. It definitely felt like something you'd eat during a Hawkins movie night.

Like

Potbelly Menu
Potbelly Menu
Sep 07

At The Potbelly Menu, we craft real sandwiches done right—perfectly toasted and packed with quality ingredients for bold, satisfying flavor in every bite. Our signature subs like the meat-loaded Big Italian and messy-good Meatball prove deli sandwiches don’t have to be boring.

Like

Jorja Jorja belle
Jorja Jorja belle
May 09

We tried the Stranger Things Pizza and it was a total throwback to the '80s! The packaging was super cool with the show's theme, and the Greggs pizza itself was surprisingly tasty—crispy crust, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of spice. It definitely felt like something you'd eat during a Hawkins movie night.

Edited
Like

Arshad abbas
Arshad abbas
Feb 21

We tried the Stranger Things Pizza, and it was a unique and delicious experience! The flavors were bold, and the toppings had a fun, nostalgic twist that any fan of the show would appreciate. If you're looking for more exciting food options, why not check out a Shake Shack near you? Find a location here: Shake Shack Near Me. 🍕🍔🔥

Like

Your go-to source for honest pizza reviews, local pizzeria spotlights, and the latest pizza trends in Indianapolis. We may earn a small commission through affiliate links, which helps support the site at no extra cost to you. All opinions are our own.

🍕

© 2020-2025 Indy Pizza Blog - Contact indypizzablog@gmail.com

© Copyright
bottom of page