ALL POSTS

On a quick stop in West Lafayette, we checked out Mad Mushroom near Purdue University. The massive, quirky space set the tone, but the real highlight was the food—cheesy, well-balanced Cheesestix and a solid pepperoni pizza with a slightly sweet, sturdy crust. Add in a standout garlic dipping sauce, and it’s easy to see why it’s a late-night staple for students.

This is our look-book of pizza companions, including some of the best garlic bread, cheesy bread, and breadsticks in Indianapolis. This...